POLS-1000 Final
-
What is federalism?
- System of gov where authority to make laws and raise revenue is divided between national and regional gov
-
What are federal constitutions and federal societies?
- Legal and sociological approaches to federalism
-
What benefits does federalism combine?
- Greater size (economy and security)
- Retention of regional control and recognition of diversity
-
What sustains a federal state?
- Sense of political nationality or community
- Belief that status quo is preferable to consequences of break-up
-
When is a federal union likely to be questioned?
- When the conditions sustaining the system no longer exist or are under pressure
-
When forming its gov, what were some issues between the colonies?
- Some Ontario (or CAD West) politicians favored a unitary system of gov
- Most other colony leaders were unwilling to give up power to new national gov
-
What colonies or provinces supported what gov?
- Ontario favoured unitary gov
- Quebec wanted to retain control over culture
- Maritime provinces insistent on federal form of gov
-
What did provisions of the Constitution Act 1867 declare the form of gov would be?
- Federal gov was expected to be the superior level of gov
-
What is quasi federalism?
- System of gov that mixes both federal and unitary features
- Power divided into central authority and smaller regions
- Strong bias towards the central gov
-
What are the quasi-federal features of the constitution and what did they do?
- Reservation and disallowance
- Allowed federal gov to review, delay, or void provincial legislation.
- What is the Paramountcy Doctrine?
- Allows court to render a law inoperative when faced with two conflicting laws between different forms of gov
- Federal law prevails
- What is the emergency doctrine?
- Emergencies Act gives progressively broader powers to PM and Cabinet under 4 different types of emergencies
- What acts broadened the emergency doctrine?
- POGG: local prohibition case (1896)
- Board of Commerce (1922)
- Anti-inflation Act (1976)
- What have courts supported Ottawa doing in relations to interprovincial trade?
- Broader interpretation of Ottawa’s power to regulate interprovincial trade
- What is fiscal federalism?
- Practice of allocating revenue raising and expenditure responsibilities across different gov levels
- What is the root problem of fiscal federalism?
- Gap between the cost of provincial responsibilities
- Province’s revenue raising
- What has Ottawa done in regards to fiscal federalism in CAD?
- Helped finance share-cost programs administered by provinces
- What do court rulings do during conflicts between Ottawa and the provinces?
- Do not provide final word in jurisdictional conflicts but can provide a basis for further governmental negotiations
- What was Alberta’s 2021 referendum about?
- Gov’s commitment to making equalization payments being removed from the constitution
- What are some more current issues relating to Alberta?
- Alberta Sovereignty Act
- CPP
- What are the various political parties in Canada?
- Conservative Party New Democratic Party Liberal Party Le Bloc Quebecois
- People’s Party Green Party
- What are the various functions of political parties?
- Integrating citizens into pol system
- Developing policy
- Elite recruitment
- Organizing gov
- Structuring vote and organizing public opinion
- Interest aggression
- What are brokerage parties?
- Pol party that focuses on inflexible policy positions in favor of an adaptable centrist style of politics
- What are Canada’s two historically dominant political parties?
- Conservative party
- Liberal party
- How far back can the Conservative and Liberal parties be traced back to?
- To the shifting coalitions in the united province of CAD in the 1840s and 1850s
- What is patronage?
- Support, encouragement, or financial aid by an individual or org to another person or group
- What have Canada’s dominant pol parties continued to do ideologically?
- Continued to be more flexible, opportunistic, dominated by leaders, and wary of ideological appeals to the electorate
- What does brokerage theory claim about Canada’s dominant political parties?
- They do not appeal to specific socio-economic groupings and lack cohesive ideological visions
- Parties are flexible and opportunistic because this behavior is necessary to preserve the fragile unity of the nation
- What is the centrist style of politics also known as?
- Big tent
- What is the centrist or “big tent” style of politics necessary for?
- To form a gov under an election system like CADs
- What type of governments rule under proportional reprsentation?
- Multi-party coalition gov
- What does brokerage politics not permit?
- Some interest and points of view to be adequately expressed through major parties
- Where are marginalized interests and views expressed in brokerage politics?
- Other political parties, mainly third parties
- What are some Canadian third-parties?
- Progressives Social Credit CCF-CDP Reform/Alliance BQ Green Party PPC
- When was the rise of the Green Party?
- 1983
- When was the rise of the Reform Party?
- 1987
- When was the rise of the Bloc Quebecois?
- 1990
- When was Canada a two-party system?
- From 1867-1930
- Small blip in 1921
- What was formed in 1921?
- Progressive party
- Why was the progressive party formed in 1921?
- By those in agriculture who thought 2 main parties were too focused on big cities rather than the farming community
- When did Canada have a two-and-a-half-party system?
- 1935-1988
- What created the two-and-a-half-party system?
- Formation of the NDP (once the CCF)
- When did Canada have a multi-party system?
- 1993-present day
- What does realignment refer to in regards to politics?
- Involves a durable change in the parties bases of electoral support
- What was thought to happen to the Bloc Quebecois?
- Thought that they would disappear from the scene after capturing the second most seats in 1993
- 30 years later this has not happened and the BQ experienced a renaissance in 2019, 2021, and 2025
- In the third phase of Canadian politics has a realignment taken place?
- no
- What was a short lived realignment phenomenon among Quebec voters?
- NDP strong showing in 2011 and then to a lesser degree in 2015
- Who competes for seats in the maritimes?
- Liberals and conservatives
- In 2015 and 2019 the liberals won
- Who dominates voting in Ontario?
- Conservatives in much of the West
- However the NDP has strongholds in some parts of the West and in Urban areas
- What type of electoral system does Canada have?
- First past the post
- Single-member, simple plurality
- What is argued about Canada’s electoral system in regards to representation?
- It produces distorted representation
- What types of parties are rewarded by Canada’s electoral system?
- Awards single most popular party and parties with regionally concentrated support
- Under-rewards parties with wide but not deep support
- What do defenders of Canada’s electoral system argue?
- Produces a stable majority gov
- Also point out faults in proportional representation
- Historically, what was voting behavior like amongst the liberal party?
- Greatest strength among French-speaking, Catholic, and Quebec voters
- Were successful in representing the ideological center of CAD politics
- Historically, what was voting behavior like amongst the conservative party?
- More successful with Protestants, anglophones, and westerners
- Historically, what was voting behavior like amongst the CCF-NDP?
- Support from unionized workers, some parts of western CAD farming communities, intellectuals, and voters in urban areas
- What were party finances and campaign spending like pre-1974?
- No transparency
- Most of the major parties’ money came from big businesses
- NDP depended on union contributions and received a large number of small contributions from individuals
- What did the Election Expenses Act of 1974 and changes to the Income Tax Act do to party finances and campaign spending?
- Provided transparency
- Tax credits to donors
- Established both paid and free broadcast time during campaigns
- What did most parties do after the 1974 financial reforms?
- Increased their number and dependence on individual contributions
- What did the liberal and conservative party rely on after the 1974 financial reforms?
- Continued to remain largely dependent on corporate money
- What did the NDP rely on after the 1974 financial reforms?
- Union contributions
- What was removed, relating to party finances, beginning in 2004?
- Public subsidies to all parties based on results of previous elections
- What does the post 2004 party financing model look like?
- Private donations strictly limited
- Public subsidies to parties phased out
- Limits on spending by 3rd parties (non registered) during campaigns
- Limits on contributions to contestants in party leadership campaigns
- Paid access oppourtunities continue
- What is the maximum amount that can be privately donated to political parties?
- $1,775
- When were public subsidies phased out and how much were they worth?
- In 2015
- $1.95 per vote
- What was the US election spending in 2020?
- 14 billion
- What was Canada’s election spending in 2019?
- 121.5 million
- How much money was spent per resident in both Canada and the US on elections?
- US 3.23 per resident
- What percentage of spending do the liberal, conservatives, and NDP spend on advertising?
- Liberals 53% Conservative 55% NDP 44%
- What type of advertising do most pol parties spend their money on?
- TV advertising
- What did Lord Durham state about Upper/Lower Canada in 1839?
- Two nations warring in the bosom of a single state
- What was “La revanche des berceaux” and what does it mean?
- Revenge of the cradles
- 19th century to mid 20th century movement
- What was the goal of “La revanche des berceaux”?
- Aimed to maintain French-Canadian cultural, religious, and political strength
- Was “La revanche des berceaux” successful?
- It maintained the francophone share of CADs population until the 2nd half of the 20th century
- What do Quebec immigrants do that causes a decline in the francophone population?
- Overwhelmingly choose English as the language of education for their kids
- What was the % of Francophone population in Canada in 1971 and 2021?
- 27.2% in 1971 21.4% in 2021
- What do provincial language laws restrict?
- The language choice available to immigrants for their kids education
- What has happened to the French-speaking population in Quebec during this century?
- It has been in steady decline
- Why is Quebec’s French-speaking population in the decline?
- Largely due to immigrants with mother tongues other than French and English opting to use English as their home language
- What is the French speaking population like outside of Quebec?
- In all provinces it continues to lose members to the English majority
- Who described the phenomenon the “bilingual belt”?
- Richard Joy in “Languages in Conflict”
- What have studies shown will lead to the collapse of francophone communities outside of Quebec?
- Aging populations
- Low birth rates
- Marriage to non-francophones
- Lack of supportive social and economic milieus for French Speakers
- What has happened to the level of bilingualism in Canada?
- Increased in recent decades mainly among younger Canadians
- Where is Canada’s highest level of bilingualism?
- In Quebec
- What has been heralded as a guarantee bilingualism will survive outside of Quebec?
- Immersion education
- What is a potential flaw of immersion education?
- Receptive bilinguals
- Those who can understand a second language but cannot produce it fluently
- What did French-Canadian nationalism emerge as/ out of?
- Emerged originally as a system of self defense
- What does “La survivance” mean for French-Canadian nationalists?
- Survival in the face of anglicizing, materialistic pressures
- What did Henri Bourassa declare inseperable?
- Preservation of the French language and the Catholic religion
- What demonstrated the weakness of traditional nationalism’s hymn to the pastoral vocations of French Canadians?
- Emigration of hundred of thousands of Quebeckers to northeastern US during the 1800s
- What was an issue preventing traditional nationalist’s vision for society?
- Anglophone control of the economy
- Quebec was becoming an urban-industrialized society like the rest of NA
- What does “Maîtres chez nous” mean and what is it linked to?
- Masters in our own house
- Linked to The Quiet Revolution, a time of rapid change in Quebec in the 60s
- What did ascendant nationalism of the 60s provide an understanding of?
- Quebec’s history, its economy, and social structure based on language and dependency
- What did the dependency perspective portray Quebec as?
- A society whose evolution has been shaped and distorted by English Canadian economic and political dominance
- What was the solution the dependency theory suggested?
- Quebec take control of their economic and political destiny
- What created united reformers in Quebec in the 60s?
- Opposition to Maurice Duplessis
- The “unholy alliance”
- What was the “unholy alliance”?
- When Nationalist Bourassa formed an alliance with anti-nationalist Tories to defeat Sir Wilfred Laurier.
- Under the Quiet Revolution, what was there a split between?
- Federalists and separatists
- What did federalists, such as Pierre Trudeau, believe in?
- National government and the possibility of national bilingualism
- What did separatists such as, Rene Levesque, believe in?
- The protection of the French language and culture was best guaranteed by the Quebec state and independence
- What is Bill 101, La Charte de la langue française?
- A territorial model of language rights
- What does Bill 101 do?
- Establishes French as the official language of Quebec
- Limits the use of or access to other languages in education, provincial, and local public services
- What does 2022’s Bill 96 do?
- Strengthens the Charter of the French Language, making French the mandatory language of commerce, business, and government services in Quebec
- What does Bill 23 represent?
- Act representing the laicity (laïcité) of the state
- What does Bill 21 do?
- Prevents public sector workers from wearing religious symbols (separation of church and state)
- What does the Official Languages Act 1969 do?
- Established English and French as having equal status in all federal institutions
- Guaranteed service in either language
- What were the goals of the Official Languages Act?
- Public’s right to be served in official language of choice
- Equitable representation of anglophones and francophones in public service positions
- Ability of public servants to work in language of their choice
- What did sections 16-23 of the Charter’s guarantees of language rights do?
- Elevated language rights to a constitutional status
- Ensured mandatory bilingualism in Parliament, courts, and federal services,
- Strengthened minority language education rights.
- What is Canada’s language rights model based on?
- Concept of Canada as a bilingual country in which an individuals language rights are portable across provinces
- What has happened to anglophone and francophone representation?
- Anglophone rep on slight decline
- Francophone rep increasing
- Are francophone overrepresented in Canada?
- In relationship to their share of population, yes
- Are Quebec francophones attached to Canada?
- No, out of every Canadian population they have the least attachment to CAD
- (stats in slideshow)
- Do foreigners know much about Canada?
- NO
- What do Canadian’s tend to be like?
- Idealist who believe in the effectiveness of soft power
- What do realists’ stress?
- Importance of hard power including military capacity and economic sanctions
- What is idealist framework also known as?
- Liberal or constructivist framework
- What does liberalist framework emphasize?
- Potential for diplomacy
- Multilateral co-operation
- Structures of international governance to control and resolve international conflict
- What generated a nationalist backlash in Canada from the end of WWII to the mid 70s?
- Economic and military integration between CAD and the US
- What did nationalists argue about Canada and the US integrating economically and militarily?
- Undermined Canadian political sovereignty, cultural distinctiveness, and economic independence
- Are idealists more likely to be nationalists or continentalists?
- Nationalist
- Wary of CAD being too closely tied to the US
- Are realists more likely to be nationalists or continentalists?
- Continentalists
- Believe ties with the US are the best way to protect and promote CADs economic and security interests
- What has Canada’s economy always been dependent on?
- Markets abroad
- What was Sir John A. Macdonald’s National Policy of 1879?
- A central, protectionist economic strategy designed to foster Canadian industrial growth, integrate the national economy, and secure the West.
- What did Sir John A. Macdonald’s National Policy of 1879 do?
- High tariffs on foreign manufactured goods
- Accelerated transcontinental railway construction (CPR)
- Rapid Western settlement.
- Up until the recent election of Donald Trump what did a majority of Canadians think about free trade?
- Supported free trade with the US and free trade in general
- What is a major debate about Canadian globalization?
- How and in what instances it can/ should be controlled
- Whether our economic ties need to be diversified
- Who creates the index of globalization, what does it include?
- Swiss Federal Institute of Technology
- Includes economic, social, and political globalization
- What was the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT)?
- Multilateral treaty designed to boost post-WWII economic recovery by reducing tariffs, quotas, and subsidies
- What did GATT lead to the creation of?
- World Trade Organiziation in 1995
- What is free trade agreement between North American countries?
- Was NAFTA (North American free trade agreement)
- Now CUSMA (Canada-United States-Mexico agreement)
- What important theme of the political left has now become an issue on the political right?
- Anti-globalization
- Why has made anti-globalization a bigger issue?
- Populist parties around the world (especially in Europe)
- 2016 US presidential election saw Trump and Sanders critical of globalization
- Brexit
- Where can critics of globalization be found in Canada?
- Social science academics
- Media elite
- Labour movement leadership
- NDP
- Religious and social justice orgs
- Environmentalist and nationalist groups
- What percent of Canadian exports of goods and services go to the US?
- Over 70%
- 20-25% of CADs GDP
- What percent of Canada’s imports of goods and services come from the US?
- 50-60%
- What is Canada’s largest source of foreign direct investment?
- US which currently accounts for half of CADs FDI
- What caused the value of trade between the US and Canada to more than triple?
- Free Trade Agreement of 1989
- What does Canada provide for the US?
- Major source of foreign important for 30/50 states
- Destination for over half the value of US automotive exports
- Largest foreign supplier of energy
- What would ending Alberta’s petroleum exports to the US do to Canada and the US?
- Decimate the provincial economy, immediate drop in CADs GDP by 4%
- Not much for the US, Alberta’s petroleum exports only account for 8% of the petroleum used
- What would happen to Canada and the US if the border was closed to automotive parts and vehicles from Canada?
- Represent an immediate 10% loss in ON’s GDP
- Impact on the overall US economy would amount to less than 1% of their GDP
- Why did Canadian businesses lobby for free trade in the 80s?
- Due to dependence on a single market
- Due to ineffectiveness of the “Third Option” in 1972
- Growing American protectionism
- What did NAFTA create?
- Architecture of dispute settlement rules, agencies, and monitoring requirements
- When was NAFTA replaced with CUSMA?
- 2016 after election of Trump
- What has reinforced the asymmetrical economic relationship between CAD and the US?
- policies from the FTA
- NAFTA/ CUSMA
- The Auto Pact
- CAD-US Defense Production Agreement
- What do many Canadian governments support to dilute US dominance?
- Multilateralism
- What is multilateralism?
- Practice of three or more nations coordinating policies and cooperating to address shared global challenges
- What are some multilateral organizations Canada participates in?
- UN
- NATO
- World Bank
- OECD
- WTO
- What are 2 prominent examples of Canada refusing or rejecting US interest?
- 2003 refusal to support war on Iraq
- 2004 rejection to participate in US-led missile defense system
- Both did not have a large impact on the US
- What event limited Canada’s ability to differ from the US on certain issues?
- 9/11
- How did 9/11 affect Canada and US relations?
- New US border security, air travel, and immigration
- CAD had to co-ordinate policies with the US
- What are the main sources of immigration to Canada?
- Countries of the developing world
- Is Canada open to foreign students?
- Yes, it is one of the world’s most open countries towards them
- What is the movement of people believed to contribute towards?
- Understanding of other societies and culture
- Aspect of soft power
- What is Canada’s military footprint like today?
- Currently smaller
- CADs UN peacekeeping missions dropped from 3000 peacekeepers in the 60-80s to five dozen today
- Why was the reason for Canada’s recent military engagements?
- Its membership in NATO
- (specific engagement in lecture slides)
- What is a potential are of military concern for Canada?
- CAD’s claims to territory and waters in the Arctic
- Would increasing Canada’s military spending make a difference geopolitically?
- No
- CAD has 14th largest defense budget but this amount makes up 0.02% of the combined budgets of the US and China
- What did Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland say in regards to Canada’s defense spending?
- Important to spend more on defense because relying on US security umbrella would make CAD a client state